I first realized Neil was a liar at the Saint Astor Hotel charity night.

At that moment, I hadn't seen the photo yet.

I was standing by the side door of the exhibition hall, armed with a cotton swab and a magnifying glass, performing a delicate inspection of a nineteenth-century shipping ledger. The auction house staff had called me in at the last minute to stabilize the document; they were terrified the display conditions would cause the existing cracks to spiderweb.

"How much longer, Miss Milligan?" a staff member asked, keeping his voice low.

"Three minutes," I replied, not looking up from the fibers. "Make sure no one touches the glass case. Especially anyone wearing rings."

"Understood."

He hurried off. Behind me, the muffled symphony of the gala—the rhythmic click of stilettos, the scuff of polished Oxfords, and the crystalline clink of champagne flutes—blended into a generic hum.

Most of the guests tonight didn't know who I was, nor did they care to. To them, I was just a ghost in the shadows, a girl who spent her life mending old paper.

I’d never been one for the spotlight. Neil used to say I was at my most natural when I was lost in my work. He’d also promised that once he finished up with his firm's business tonight, he’d come to pick me up for a late dinner by the river.

Today was our third anniversary.

I had a gift waiting for him in my bag: a vintage silver cufflink I’d scouted from a second-hand shop. On the back, in tiny, elegant script, were the words: Don't lose your heart.

It felt a little sentimental, maybe even cliché, but Neil was the type to appreciate that sort of thing. He always teased me for my love of small, meaningful trinkets.

"Ivy."

I turned to find Miranda Blythe standing a few paces away. She was the picture of auction-house elegance in a structured black gown, her hair swept up perfectly, holding an untouched glass of champagne.

"Are you doing all right?" she asked.

"Fine." I carefully pressed a lifted edge of the paper back into place. "Just give me two more minutes."

Miranda glanced toward the massive screen at the center of the hall, her expression unreadable.

"There’s a temporary segment being added to the program," she said. "The organizers are playing a few video tributes from their partners. Stay close. If someone needs an expert to explain the provenance of this ledger on stage, I’ll need you."

"I won't wander off."

"I know." She hesitated. "And Ivy? Don't drink anything someone hands you unless you saw it poured."

My hand faltered, the cotton swab hovering over the paper.

"Why?"

Miranda gave a faint, weary smile. "Experience."

She didn't elaborate. Fifteen years at Belmont Auctioneers had clearly shown her things I hadn't yet encountered. I nodded and applied the final bit of adhesive, ensuring the paper fibers were secure before snapping my tool kit shut.

Across the hall, the lights dimmed.

A light ripple of applause followed as the host’s voice boomed through the speakers.

"Ladies and gentlemen, thank you for joining us at the Saint Astor. To begin our evening, we’d like to share a few words from our valued partners and donors."

I didn't pay much attention at first, until the screen flickered to life and Neil’s face filled the frame.

He was wearing the charcoal suit I’d picked out for him, standing in an office I didn't recognize. The lighting made him look soft, approachable—his eyes clear and his lips curved into just the right amount of a professional smile.

"Is that the young man from Harper & Associates?" someone nearby whispered.

"That’s him. I heard he’s rising through the ranks quite fast."

I instinctively took a step forward.

Neil hadn't mentioned he was recording a tribute for tonight. He’d told me the firm was swamped and that he’d be late.

On the screen, he looked directly into the camera as if he were speaking to someone very close to him.

"It’s an honor to support tonight’s restoration project," he said. "We preserve old things because we believe they still have value. I believe people are the same way."

A few guests chuckled warmly.

I nearly smiled myself. It was such a Neil thing to say. He’d always been a master of social grace.

"Tonight, I’d also like to take this opportunity to thank someone special."

My fingers tightened around the handle of my kit.

Neil looked down, a bashful smile playing on his lips.

"She doesn't like the spotlight. She always says all she knows how to do is mend broken paper, but in my eyes, she’s been mending my faith in life every single day."

Heads began to turn in my direction.

I felt a sudden heat rise in my cheeks.

"Ivy," Neil said, "happy third anniversary."

A collective, sympathetic "aww" rippled through the hall.

Standing in the shadows, I suddenly didn't know what to do with my hands. The tweezers inside my kit gave a tiny, metallic clink. I felt a confusing mix of embarrassment and an overwhelming urge to laugh.

How had he managed to hide this from me? He’d been so convincing this morning about being too busy for dinner.

Miranda looked back at me, a flicker of surprise in her eyes. I shook my head, silently conveying that I was just as shocked as she was.

"When tonight is over," Neil continued on screen, "I want to take her to that place she’s always dreamed of. And I hope she’ll let me stay by her side for every year to come."

The room erupted in applause.

My chest ached with a sudden, sharp joy. I reached into my bag, feeling the cool metal of the vintage cufflink. I decided right then to forgive him for being so busy lately, and for not answering my texts last night.

You shouldn't spend your life doubting the person you love.

That was when my phone vibrated.

Expecting a text from Neil, I pulled it out and looked down.

There was no text. Only a photo.

In the image, white sheets were tangled in a mess of shadows. A woman’s hand rested flat against a man’s bare chest. Her nails were painted a deep, blood red. There was no ring on her finger, but around her wrist was a familiar silver buckle.

I recognized that buckle instantly.

It was The Silver Cipher—the exclusive invitation piece for the Saint Astor’s inner circle tonight. To prevent forgeries, every buckle had tiny, handcrafted notches along the edge. I had helped Miranda verify the samples this morning, even complaining that the markings were too shallow and easy to miss.

The woman in the photo had slender wrists and a small mole near the base of her thumb.

It was Leah Russo. My best friend.

I stared at the hand, my mind going blank for several seconds.

On the big screen, Neil’s voice was still playing.

"She made me believe that stability is the rarest kind of luck."

More applause.

All I could hear was the frantic, hollow drumming of my own heart.

My phone buzzed again.

This time, it was text.

"He’s a little tied up and can’t pick you up right now. Happy anniversary, Ivy."

I looked up at the screen.

Neil was still there, looking tender and clean, the kind of man you could trust with your whole life.

I looked back down at the photo.

The man’s face wasn't fully visible—only his jawline and Adam’s apple were in frame.

But I knew that necktie. I had ironed it for him this morning. Deep blue, with a tiny, stubborn crease near the knot.

I’d even suggested he wear a different one, but he’d insisted it didn't matter since he was "just going to the office."

Apparently, his office was a hotel room.

I don't know how long I stood there, frozen.

Someone leaned in close. "Miss Milligan? Are you all right?"

I looked up. It was the staff member from earlier.

"You look pale."

"I’m fine," I said, my voice sounding like it belonged to a stranger. "Just... low blood sugar, I think."

"Do you need to sit down?"

"No."

I clutched the phone in my palm, my nails digging into my skin.

The crowd was still clapping for Neil.

As his tribute ended, the host smiled broadly. "What a moving confession. It seems tonight isn't just a night for charity, but for romance as well."

Someone raised a glass toward me.

"Congratulations, dear."

I looked at her and forced a jagged smile.

"Thank you."

As I spoke, I felt a surge of nausea so strong I nearly gagged.

I wanted to run. But I couldn't move my feet—not because I was still in love with Neil, but because I suddenly realized the photo hadn't been sent to me by accident.

It was timed perfectly to land just as Neil’s tribute aired, exactly when every eye in the room was fixed on me.

Leah knew I would be standing right here.

She probably even knew the exact second Neil’s face would appear on that screen.

This was a choreographed execution.

My phone lit up again.

This wasn't an unknown number. It was Leah.

"Don't make a scene, Ivy. Everyone is watching."

I gripped the phone and slowly raised my head.

On the other side of the hall, Leah Russo was standing by the dessert table. She was wearing a shimmering silver-grey gown, her hair cascading over her shoulders, a glass of red wine in her hand.

She was looking at me.

Our eyes met across the crowded room.

She didn't look away. She didn't even look guilty. She actually smiled.

A sudden, violent urge to walk over and demand to know why she was doing this flared up in my chest.

But before I could move, she lifted her hand and gave her wrist a slight, mocking shake.

The Silver Cipher glinted under the chandeliers.

The photo was real.

"Ivy?" Miranda was at my side again, her voice much lower than before. "What happened?"

I handed her the phone.

She took one look, and her face went stone-cold.

"Who sent this?"

"I don't know," I said. "But that’s Leah in the photo."

Miranda didn't ask if I was sure.

She just handed the phone back and cast a sharp glance toward the screen.

"Do you want to leave?"

"I need to leave."

"Go through the side exit."

"No," I heard myself say.

Miranda looked at me, and I couldn't even explain why I’d said it.

Maybe it was because of Leah’s text: "Don't make a scene, everyone is watching."

She wanted me to be humiliated. She wanted to see me crumble while the room was still echoing with applause. She wanted me to be the punchline of a joke I hadn't known I was in.

I couldn't run. Not yet.

"I need to confirm something," I said.

"What?"

I opened the photo again and zoomed in.

Miranda frowned. "Ivy, this isn't the time for work."

"This is the only work that matters right now."

I stared at the Silver Cipher on Leah’s wrist.

There was a faint, etched line on the edge of the buckle. It looked like a letter—perhaps an 'R'—followed by what could be a 7 or a 1. The line was partially obscured by the curve of her wrist. When I had checked the samples this morning, I remembered that every inner-circle buckle was numbered, corresponding to the guest list and seating zones.

Leah wasn't on the VIP list for tonight.

She had no business having one of these buckles.

If she had one, it meant someone had given it to her.

And Neil didn't have one either.

"Miranda," I whispered, "can you check the VIP invitation log?"

She studied me for a few beats. "I can. But first, tell me what you're planning to do."

"I want to know who this buckle belongs to."

"You should be finding that man and demanding an explanation."

"I’ll find him," I said. "But I’m not going to him crying."

Miranda remained silent for a moment.

"Follow me."

She led me around the dessert table toward the back of the exhibition hall. As we passed Leah, the other woman called out my name softly.

"Ivy."

I stopped. She was looking at me with a look of pure, smug triumph.

"Did you get my gift?"

I heard Miranda take a sharp, indrawn breath.

I looked Leah in the eye. "I got it."

Leah smiled. "Then I suppose you understand now?"

"Understand what?"

"That some things can't be fixed, no matter how much you try to mend them." She swirled her wine. "Relationships are like that. People too."

I looked at her. Her lipstick was a deep red, perfectly matching the nails in the photo.

"How long has this been going on?" I asked.

Leah arched a brow. "Does it matter?"

"It matters to me."

"Why? So you can calculate exactly how long you’ve been a fool?"

The words hit me with surgical precision.

I thought I would cry.

I didn't.

My eyes burned with a dry, searing heat, and my chest felt like it was being crushed, but the tears stayed locked away.

"Leah," I said, "do you really think if you humiliate me first, I won't have the strength to ask other questions?"

The smile faltered slightly.

"What is that supposed to mean?"

"Who gave you that Silver Cipher?"

Leah’s fingers tightened around her glass.

If I didn't spend every day analyzing old paper, faded ink, and hidden marks, I might have missed it. She knew she wasn't supposed to have that buckle.

"What are you talking about?" she snapped.

"You know exactly what I’m talking about."

"Ivy, don't make this any uglier for yourself." She stepped closer, her voice dropping to a hiss. "Neil has been tired of you for a long time. You and your dusty papers, your smells of mold and old archives. Did you really think he wanted to spend his life listening to you talk about paper fibers and ink oxidation?"

"So he chose you instead?"

"At least I know how to make him happy."

Miranda spoke up, her voice like ice. "Miss Russo, this is a charity gala, not a cheap theater."

Leah looked at her, the bravado slipping just an inch.

"Ms. Blythe, I’m just talking to a friend."

"You don't have friends," I said.

Leah’s face finally twisted into a scowl.

I tucked my phone into my bag and gripped the handle of my tool kit.

"I’m going to find out where that buckle came from. You can tell me now, or I can find out on my own."

Leah glared at me.

"You’ll never find out."

"Watch me."

I turned to walk away.

Leah’s voice followed me. "Neil won't see you. You should just accept it and go home."

I froze in my tracks.

"What else did he say?"

She laughed. "He said you were far too naive."

This time, my fingertips actually trembled.

I realized then that this wasn't just a simple affair. Neil wasn't just cheating.

He was waiting for me to be publicly shamed. He and Leah had worked together to put me under these lights, to let the world watch me be blessed, and then to tear me open themselves.

"Let's go," Miranda whispered.

I followed her.

We entered the back office, and Miranda locked the door before booting up her laptop.

"Sit down, Ivy."

"I’ll stand."

"Ivy."

It was the first time she’d ever used that tone with me.

I sat.

The moment I did, my knees turned to water.

Miranda entered her credentials and pulled up the VIP guest log.

"Give me the phone."

I handed it over.

She zoomed in on the photo, focusing entirely on the edge of the Silver Cipher.

"Can you make out the number?"

"It’s incomplete," I said, leaning in. "It looks like an R. The next character could be a 7 or a 1. The notch is hidden by the skin of her wrist."

"Zone R is the seating for private clubs tonight."

"What kind of clubs?"

Miranda didn't answer immediately.

I looked at her. "Miranda?"

She sighed and clicked on the guest list for Zone R.

The silence in the office was broken only by the hum of the computer fan.

There were twelve seats in Zone R.

Most of the names were strangers to me.

But the final entry didn't have a name. It only had a small, red icon.

The note next to it read: The Vermilion Society. All-access.

A cold shiver crawled up my spine.

"What is that?" I asked.

Miranda closed the laptop, her movements slower than before.

"That is a place you shouldn't touch."

"But Neil touched it."

"Then he’s either a fool or he’s been targeted."

I looked down at the photo on my phone. The hand, the tie, the buckle... and there, in the blurred corner, that faint red badge.

It had been there all along.

Someone had arranged Neil and Leah in that photo, and someone had sent it to me. Not to break my heart, but to make sure I saw that badge.

Miranda stood by the door, blocking out the sound of the party outside.

"Ivy, listen to me. Go home. Lock your door. Sleep. Deal with Neil tomorrow."

"If I wait until tomorrow, he’ll have cleared the trail."

"You aren't a detective."

"I know."

"And you aren't the kind of person who can walk into a place like that."

"I know that too."

Miranda searched my face, trying to see if I’d lost my mind.

Maybe I had lost a piece of it. But the part that remained was sharper than ever.

Neil could stop loving me. Leah could betray me. But they weren't going to use my career and my access to set me up, and they weren't going to drop a dangerous secret into my life and expect me to just bow out.

I picked up my tool kit.

"Where are you going?" Miranda asked.

"To find the owner of that buckle."

"Ivy."

I looked back.

Miranda’s expression was grim. "The Vermilion Society isn't just some social club. People who go in there don't always get to choose when they leave."

I tightened my grip on the kit.

"Then I won't go in," I said. "I’ll just look at the door."

I was lying, and Miranda knew it, but she didn't call me out. Instead, she pulled a temporary staff badge from her desk drawer and handed it to me.

"In thirty minutes, an auction house van is heading to The Vermilion Society to deliver some documents. If you’re hell-bent on this, take the van. Don't take a cab. It’s too conspicuous."

I took the badge, my throat tight.

"Thank you."

"Don't thank me yet," she said. "If I don't hear from you by ten, I’m calling the police."

I nodded.

Before I left the office, I looked at the photo one last time. The red badge in the corner was so blurry it was almost invisible.

But I had already memorized its shape.

Neil’s tribute was still echoing in my head, a hollow reminder that some things were never real to begin with.

I pushed open the back door, and the cold air of the Saint Astor alleyway hit me like a slap.

My phone buzzed again.

A new message from the unknown number.

"Stop now, Miss Milligan. The Vermilion isn't for people like you."

I stared at the words for a moment, then slid the phone into my pocket.

I walked toward the black van idling at the end of the alley.

I didn't look back.

The Billionaire's Contract Wife — Chapter 5: The Heir in Black

You Might Also Like

No Recommendations